Becoming an Ultracyclist

Randoneurring: That's fancy French for "Loving the Bike!"

11 November 2008

Prop H8

The LA Times today published the Registrar's tally of votes, pro and con, on Prop 8.

On the surface this is what I noticed. Affluent cities voted No. Poor cities voted Yes. Cities with a large, affluent white base voted No. Cities with large minority communities voted Yes. Affluent cities with large minority populations voted Yes.

Education, it seems, was not as influential in tipping the vote as traditional religious values were. Ethnic communities with strong religious views tipped this thing in LA County. I believe that my immigrant cousins, Catholic and Protestant, voted Yes en masse.

To get the various ethnic groups to accept gay marriage as a basic human right is going to be very, very difficult. Homophobia--violently aggressive homophobia--is de rigueur in many foreign countries. Traditional religious beliefs, beliefs that are fundamentally homophobic, only give these people a deeper rationale to oppose the extension of marriage to gays and lesbians.

The strategy to extend full rights to gays and lesbians has to be secular and it has to be defined beyond that of a fundamental human right.

If marriage has so many meanings, the state has to assume the responsibility of choosing a single meaning, one that can be agreed upon by everyone. The mistake the LGBT community is making about marriage is the same mistake that the religious right is making: they're trying to narrowly glom "marriage." For the LGBT community, marriage is an equal rights issue. For the religious right, it is a sacrament. In truth, the word is too pregnant with social and historical meaning to satisfy any one constituency. Both communities are like the two mothers facing Solomon, each one demanding THE baby. Solomon offers to split the kid in half, an untenable action. So he gives the baby to one of the mothers, the right one. Well, let the religious right have their retarded baby. The state should remove itself from the marriage business and only sanction universal domestic partnership or civil unions for ALL citizens. If marriage is sacred, then let the churches that believe in the sanctity of marriage confer the sacrament to its parishioners and believers. However, when it comes to legally recognizing marriages or partnerships, let it be called a civil union.

I think secular civil unions can appeal to the right and to the more traditional ethnic groups in this state. I think civil unions will give the LGBT community equal treatment before the law.

Although all marriages can be civil unions, not all civil unions need to be called marriages.

No comments: