Becoming an Ultracyclist

Randoneurring: That's fancy French for "Loving the Bike!"

14 October 2008

Constitutional musings: amendment #2 (a working draft)

A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.

Wow. What a sentence! Does it mean that state militias have the right to bear arms on behalf of the people? Or does it mean that individuals have the right to bear arms? Ah, semantics.

A few months ago the Supreme Court (in a 5-4 decision) interpreted the second amendment from a unique perspective. Five justices believed that individual Americans--and not just the state-- have the right to own guns and keep them at home.

So sorry, but I disagree with them.

English 101

A. Sentence structure matters. The kernel of the sentence is this: A well regulated Militia... shall not be infringed. The bold phrase is the subject and the bold italicized phrase is the predicate. These two sentence fragments, when seen side by side AND as one simple sentence, evoke a tremendous amount of meaning.


1. The founders believed in maintaining the security of the nation. Security was such an important mandate that it is articulated in the Constitution's preamble. Indeed, within the body of the Constitution (article II, section 2) the executive branch is responsible for the Army and Navy as well as possessing power over the states' Militias. The Army is a federal force of arms whereas the Militia is a state force of arms. The latter, being a state body, is free to exist as long as it is regulated by the federal government. In other words, it is an an organized military force that can't supplant the primacy of the US Army or Navy. Although regulated (supervised and established) by the federal govt, state Militias are also independent. They exist at the behest of the state in order to protect property and populace.

2. The establishment of a militia is so important that its existence from state to state cannot be violated by the federal govt. In other words, the militia can't be disbanded on a whim, it can't be morphed into a chain gang. The purpose of the militia is to maintain security (think of the national guard and how it has been used to quell riots, protect civil rights, and administer aid in emergency situations.)

B. In and of itself, the simple sentence above is relatively easy to understand especially when placed in the context of the rest of the Constitution. However, there are two clauses that are sandwiched between the two sentence fragments (A well regulated Militia...shall not be infringed) that create problems. Do they have to create problems? A reader can demystify the significance of being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms by keeping to simple rules of grammar. Both clauses are dependent clauses. Following the subject, A well regulated Militia, the two clauses-- being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms--describe what a well regulated Militia is and how it should be.

being necessary to the security of a free state

This first clause is existential. It states the reason for a Militia's existence. Militias exist in order to ensure security within a law abiding state. "Free" does not mean anarchy; "free" means a State that abides by the rule of law.


the right of the people to keep and bear Arms

This second clause is also dependent. Whereas the first clause gives a reason for the Militia's existence, the second clause describes the operational composition of the militia. The militia--being an official and recognized military force--can secure a free state through the keeping and bearing of arms. "People" in this clause does not refer to individual citizens acting as singular agents; instead, "people" refers to the militia itself. And the militia is derived from We the People, a nation state.

Everyone who is a major gun proponent quotes the second clause to justify their belief that individuals have the right to bear arms. They say it is a fundamental right protected by the Constitution. But they forget that the right of the people to keep and bear Arms isn't the second amendment. Instead, it is a piece of an amendment.

In my opinion, the whole amendment articulates
a) the right of the state to protect itself against anything that would compromise its existence as a free, organized, and enlightened state;
and
b) the right of citizens to be a willing part of that endeavor.
In other words, I believe that the second amendment protects the collective--We the People-- by allowing the collective to protect itself.

The framers of the Constitution did not advocate for the proliferation of weapons among individual citizens. To do so would have been a green light to the development of paramilitary groups and vigilante mobs. The amendment begins with A well regulated Militia-- and that requires supervision, regulation, training, and law. Remember too, the framers, despite their own democratic leanings, were conditional about democracy; they were wary of most Americans. They feared their neighbors (ignorant, ill educated, poor) and the mob mentality that these people had a tendency of succumbing to. Democracy, American style, is not a town hall debate with majority rule. Democracy in America was intended to be a mediated and buffered affair: rep democracy, electoral college, the importance of wealth in an election, the two party system, etc.

Although the framers didn't trust the regular Joe, they were collectively willing to protect Joe's fundamental right to life.

Hey Joe! Drop that gun in yer hand!

No comments: